God on Trial – Frank Cottrell Boyce

Last night I went to a screening of God on Trial to mark Holocaust Memorial Day. The film is set in Auschwitz during World War II and is about a group of prisoners who decide to hold a trial against God for breaking his covenant with the Jewish people by allowing the genocide to take place.

The screenwriter, Frank Cottrell Boyce, was present at the event and answered questions from the audience about his inspiration for the film.

He had heard the story of the trial as a young man and it stuck with him. “I was just a bit daft about it really,” he said, explaining that he was moved by the fact that the story ended on a note of hope. His own faith, however, made him doubt if he was qualified write the screenplay. “I’m a Catholic. Should I be writing about a Jewish subject? It seemed quite blasphemous to have a trial of God.” He spoke to a Rabbi about it who told him that in Judaism there is a “very strong tradition of wrangling with God.” This convinced Cottrell Boyce to go ahead with the project.

He knew that for the story to work, God had to be found guilty. Cottrell Boyce asked the Rabbi for a list of arguments that might be used to make a case against God, then he sat down and read the Old Testament. “It’s a tough read. It’s a remnant of a brutal age. It’s hard to reconcile that with anything you want to believe, really.”

This research, as well interviews he had done with Holocaust survivors, provided Cottrell Boyce with the material he needed to write the screenplay. “It troubled me a lot writing this film. One of the things that held me together was talking to the people who had been there and still had their faith intact.”

When it came to rehearsing the script, Cottrell Boyce realised that his first draft focused too much on intellectual arguments. “I had to give the actors something to hold on to. The answer is not intellectual. It’s about your relationship with God.” He introduced a more human element to the story, allowing the characters to talk about their experiences at the hands of the Nazis.

One of the questions raised in the film is about the nature of goodness. Why do good people suffer? What makes a person ‘good’?

“We do get very hung up on the question of evil. I get evil. It’s just part of the evolutionary process really. Goodness is inexplicable. There should be more questions about goodness.”

Cottrell Boyce believes that the film is relevant even now, 65 years after the liberation of the concentration camp at Auschwitz, because “the Holocaust is not unprecedented and it is not alone.” He cited conflicts in Northern Ireland and Iraq as examples of atrocities happening in our own lifetime. When asked what had changed for him personally as a result of writing the film, Cottrell Boyce said that praying for him is no longer about saying please and thank you. Now he is asking ‘why?’ and “that is a fantastic gift.”


3 thoughts on “God on Trial – Frank Cottrell Boyce

  1. Wow – I am jealous. I would have loved to attend this event!
    Thank you for this post.
    And it is amazing how evil is so much easier defined than good. I suppose it has to do with intent – at least as far as being good.

    Just curious, “God for breaking his covenant with the Jewish people ” – did he mention anything about the destruction of the temples and all such other incidents when G-d did indeed break his covenant with the Jewish people? I am do not study nor am a religious person, but it fascinates me and I am curious what he had to say.

    Must have been great to hear him talk.

  2. Yes, it was a very interesting, thought provoking talk. Frank Cottrell Boyce didn’t say anything about the destruction of temples himself but the characters in the film did discuss it. I wasn’t taking notes during the film so I can’t recall what the specifics of the argument were but there is a very good post here where the debate in the film is summarised:


  3. i really really want to write a book its my dream and i would love the help! please email me and i send the 1st chap

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s